I hope you’re enjoying your first full day in New York. I asked my brother about pizza and he replied:
“I don’t know about on the east side, but on the west side there is the extremely awesome Patsy’s, a particular favourite of ours. Unless they are huge people, they should only get one large pizza, I think you can ask to have half one topping, half another. The caesar salad is also fab there.
It’s at 74th and Columbus, which is approximately a quarter of the way up from the southern end of the park. Columbus is the first avenue walking away from the park (apart from Central Park West itself which borders the park.) I’m so jealous!
It does get full though so you need to plan on going there, putting your name down and then finding a bar for 30 minutes or so.
Hope that’s of use. Do post a pizza picture if you get there.